Product/UX
EC_wireframe1.png

Zoom Mute

ZOOM MUTE (feature improvement)

Platform: Desktop

Target Audience/End user: Users who use Zoom for business meetings with co-workers, but are not Hosts or Admins.

Problem: Users frequently think they are unmuted when they are actually muted, and usually are unaware until other meeting participants tell them they are muted. This can waste precious meeting time, and/or leave users with a negative sentiment towards Zoom and/or remote meetings (it’s frustrating and embarrassing).

Approach: Since this was an issue I experienced myself (both first- and secondhand), I had a hypothesis that Zoom’s mute function made the “muted” state virtually invisible to the user.

This was confirmed by surveying other Zoom users who had also experienced the “forgotten muted state” issue.

In Universal Principles of Design (Lidwell/Holden/Butler), the authors state that “According to the principle of visibility, systems are more usable when they clearly indicate their status, the possible actions that can be performed, and the consequences of the actions once performed.”

I analyzed how the Zoom function worked, and compared it to some other mute functions in other products.

Zoom

Zoom’s Mute button is located in the left

Google Meet

Google Meet was the only other competitor that also had a comparable freemium model. It can be accessed within Gmail and by typing the URL “meet.google.com” into your web browser.

A few notable differences from Zoom:

  • Google Meet’s bottom navigation never disappears

  • Google Meet’s Mute button became a solid red when activated

  • Google Meet provides a toast notification at the top of the screen re: mic status (“Microphone on”/”Microphone off”)

Google Meet’s solid red mute button and toast notifications (“Microphone on”/”Microphone off”).

Google Meet’s solid red mute button and toast notifications (“Microphone on”/”Microphone off”).

iPhone

While not a pure competitor to Zoom, the telephone call is still a form of two-way communication that is enhanced by a mute feature. The iPhone’s mute button turns solid white (they reserve the red color for the “end call” button). The controls are also present throughout the call.

The iPhone during a phone call. The controls remain on screen during the call, and the Mute button stays solid when muted.

The iPhone during a phone call. The controls remain on screen during the call, and the Mute button stays solid when muted.

Blue Yeti Microphone

This microphone has a visual aspect to its Mute button. It flashes when the user is muted, and becomes solid when the user unmutes.

The Blue Yeti microphone, a real-world physical product, employs a mute button with a blinking light when muted, and solid when unmuted.

The Blue Yeti microphone, a real-world physical product, employs a mute button with a blinking light when muted, and solid when unmuted.


SOLUTION:

My enhanced “Mute” button.

My enhanced “Mute” button.

My super-visible “You Are Muted” indicator.

My super-visible “You Are Muted” indicator.





Combining the enhanced “mute” button and super-visible “You Are Muted” indicator.

Combining the enhanced “mute” button and super-visible “You Are Muted” indicator.

Try the clickable prototype.